That’s the height of hypocrisy

BEN Jaycock described last week how RFC is being used as a means to prevent being demoted to the base of the league pyramid.

Stourbridge and its players are being used as fall guys in Worcester's clever manoeuvres after that club's demise.

Jaycock writes that Worcester will ‘rebrand' next season as ‘Sixways Rugby', and will merge with Stourbridge in National Two West. He adds that Jim O'Toole, the CEO of the consortium which took over Worcester, does not want his new club to go the bottom of the league pyramid. (No surprise there!) No club would want the sort of punishment meted out to and London Scottish a generation ago; those two famous old clubs have never properly recovered.

O'Toole says the aim is for his re-branded club to reach the Championship within three years, with the eventual aim of getting back into the . Yet neither Worcester nor any other Premiership club objected to the new ring fence. Expecting to be promoted back into the Premiership now that they are outside that league is the height of hypocrisy.

Jaycock says Stour- bridge RFC also confir med in a letter to its members that the aim was to push for the Championship and beyond. He also writes that, not surprisingly, the family of the late Cecil Duckworth ‘are devastated to lear n of the re-branding', and believe that ‘the new owners are trying to destroy the legacy that Cecil and so many others built'.

Does the Rugby Football Union have a view on this unholy mess?

SEND YOUR COMMENTS TO:

The Rugby Paper, Tuition House, St Georges Road, Wimbledon SW19 4EU

email: newsdesk@therugbypaper.co.uk

Meanwhile, the current Championship leaders Ealing have been told they do not meet the criteria for entry to the Premiership, while the only other club to meet those criteria, Doncaster, are unlikely to finish top. Those criteria include a minimum ground capacity of 10,001; or planning consent to develop the ground to reach that figure, with a current minimum of 5,000.

Yet a look at the crowd figures for Premiership clubs in January shows that a minimum capacity of over 10,000 for promotion to the Premiership is absurd.

January 7

Falcons v Tigers, 6,500

Chiefs v Northampton Saints, 8,215

January 14

Saracens v , 8,436

January 28

Sale v Bath, 6,750

If football's Premier League was ring fenced, never again could famous old clubs such as Burnley, Sheffield United, Middlesbrough, Sunderland, Blackbur n Rovers, West Bromwich Albion, Norwich City, Preston

North End, Queens Park Rangers, Bir mingham City, Stoke City, Cardiff City, Huddersfield Town, Blackpool, Sheffield Wednesday, Ipswich Town, Bolton Wanderers, Derby County, Portsmouth and Charlton Athletic hope to regain their status in the top flight.

Yet the RFU has seen fit to ring fence English rugby's Premiership, so that clubs with equally long and fine traditions as Sunderland and company now have no hope of regaining their for mer status; think of Coventry, , Moseley, Richmond, London Scottish, Bedford and Rosslyn Park.